economics

Divisions in the U.S. EB-1 Visa: How Can Chinese Applicants Prove Their Excellence?

Published November 17, 2026 · 5 min read
SAN FRANCISCO – OCTOBER 05: A scientist works in the lab at University of California San Francisco October 5, 2009 in San Francisco, California. UCSF scientist Elizabeth Blackburn shared the 2009 Nobel Prize in medicine with Carol Greider and Jack Szostak for their discovery of how chromosomes are protected by telomeres and the enzyme telomerase. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Recent data from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has revealed notable discrepancies in approval rates for different subcategories under the Employment-Based First Preference (EB-1) category. Specifically, the approval rate for the EB-1A visa, which caters to individuals of extraordinary ability in various fields, stands at approximately 32.2%. In contrast, the EB-1B visa, designated for outstanding professors and researchers, has an impressive approval rate of around 93%.

The statistics for the third quarter of the fiscal year 2026 illustrate the differences between these two categories. The USCIS reported 1,348 approvals and 2,832 denials for EB-1A applications, with 28,874 cases still pending at the quarter’s end. For EB-1B, the agency approved 1,408 applications while only rejecting 106, leaving 1,687 cases awaiting review. It is important to note that these figures include applicants from various countries, not solely those from China. Additionally, the approvals and denials from that quarter do not exclusively reflect new applications submitted during that period.

The Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) of the USCIS released decisions in 2024 concerning two cases—one involving an EB-1A application and the other an EB-1B application. These rulings showcased distinct outcomes and underscore the complexities involved in the evaluation process.

The AAO functions as an appellate body within the USCIS framework. When a visa application is denied by the USCIS, applicants have the option to appeal to the AAO.

In the first case, a mechanical engineering doctorate holder, despite possessing 18 published academic papers, 217 citations, and 3 patents, was unsuccessful in securing EB-1B approval.

Conversely, in a second case, an economist with over twenty years of research experience and more than a hundred published articles faced an initial rejection for an EB-1A application. However, the AAO later overturned the initial denial upon appeal.

These cases highlight a critical question for professionals, particularly those from China: how does the USCIS assess an individual’s academic accomplishments, professional contributions, and international influence?

In a 2024 EB-1B appeal case, the applicant, a mechanical engineer focusing on renewable energy and electrochemical conversion technologies, presented impressive qualifications. This included a postdoctoral research background and a position as a modeling engineer at an American chemical technology firm since April 2022.

His application included three Chinese patents, 18 academic papers, and a total of 217 citations, along with participation in peer reviews and several expert recommendation letters highlighting his research capabilities. Despite meeting certain preliminary evidence standards for peer review, original contributions, and publication, the AAO ultimately determined that he did not demonstrate international recognition in his field, failing to meet the EB-1B qualifying requirements.

This case illustrates that the review process for EB-1B does not solely depend on whether the applicant has a doctoral degree, publications, or patents; rather, it requires a comprehensive evaluation of how these elements collectively establish the individual’s outstanding status in their respective academic or research fields.

On the other hand, a different EB-1A case published in November 2024 yielded a more favorable outcome. The applicant was an economist with substantial research experience, having published over a hundred articles and multiple books during his two-decade career. His professional background extended beyond academia, encompassing work in research institutions, business entities, and corporate management.

Initially, the USCIS recognized that his documentation met five categories of evidence—awards, media coverage, peer reviews, original contributions, and academic publications. However, in its overall evaluation, the agency viewed the applicant’s achievements as concentrated within a limited timeframe, falling short of demonstrating sustained national or international acclaim.

Upon appeal, the AAO acknowledged that the original assessment overlooked an award the applicant received in 2019 and failed to adequately consider his consistent publication record from 2002 to 2022, which spanned over twenty years. The AAO emphasized that when assessing eligibility for extraordinary ability, it is essential to evaluate evidence collectively rather than in isolation. Consequently, the AAO ruled in favor of the applicant, affirming his eligibility for the EB-1A classification.

It is essential to clarify that these rulings pertain to individual cases and do not guarantee similar outcomes for all applicants with comparable backgrounds.

Both EB-1A and EB-1B fall under the First Preference category for employment-based immigration to the United States, yet they have differing eligibility criteria and evidentiary requirements.

EB-1A primarily targets individuals with extraordinary ability in fields such as science, arts, education, business, or athletics. Applicants must satisfy at least three out of ten evidence criteria or receive a one-time significant international award while demonstrating sustained national or international acclaim in a holistic assessment. EB-1A applications do not necessarily require employer sponsorship.

In contrast, EB-1B is aimed at outstanding professors and researchers, typically requiring employer sponsorship from a U.S. institution and offering positions that meet specified criteria for tenure or permanent research. Applicants must have at least three years of teaching or research experience and meet at least two out of six evidence standards, which include receiving significant awards for extraordinary achievements, membership in organizations that require outstanding accomplishment for entry, published material about their work, peer-reviewed contributions, original research, and published academic works.

However, fulfilling just two standards is a preliminary requirement; the USCIS will conduct a comprehensive review to determine whether the applicant’s accomplishments substantiate international recognition in their respective fields.

Thus, while EB-1A and EB-1B belong to the same First Preference category, their approval ratios should not be the only factor considered when evaluating the relative difficulty of each option. The applicant’s professional background, job arrangements, and supporting documentation all play critical roles in determining the most suitable category for application.

Applicants for U.S. employment-based immigration typically begin with the USCIS processing their immigrant petition (Form I-140). Even if the I-140 is approved, it does not guarantee an immediate green card issuance, especially for applicants from mainland China, who must continue to wait for an available immigration visa number. According to the U.S. State Department’s visa bulletin for November 2026, the EB-1 category demonstrates two significant deadlines.

Submitting Form I-485 does not equate to automatically receiving work authorization. Applicants must submit a separate application for a work permit (Form I-765), and they can only begin employment under relevant regulations after USCIS approves and issues their work authorization document (EAD).