As China’s navy accelerates its expansion into open ocean operations, the Japanese government has initiated research on nuclear-powered submarines and is urging a quick conclusion on the possibility of incorporating them into its naval capabilities. The United States has expressed a supportive stance towards Japan’s aspirations in this regard. Should Japan break the operational limitations imposed on conventional submarines, it could significantly enhance the ability of the Japan-U.S. alliance to counter the growing capabilities of the Chinese navy in the western Pacific.
In light of these developments, the Japanese government is currently revising three core security documents, planning to include the research into nuclear-powered submarines in its formal agenda. According to multiple sources cited by Kyodo News on November 21, a draft from the government stated that “explorations will begin with the goal of reaching a conclusion as soon as possible,” and the government is considering allocating research funding starting from the 2027 fiscal year.
Furthermore, the Japan Innovation Party is not only advocating for the introduction of nuclear-powered submarines but is also calling for a reevaluation of the Three Non-Nuclear Principles. The current discussions within the Japanese government address these two issues separately; one pertains to the submarine propulsion systems, while the other concerns whether to allow foreign military vessels that are armed with nuclear weapons to enter Japanese territory during emergencies. Each topic will require distinct policy and legal considerations.
In the current National Security Strategy, the Three Non-Nuclear Principles are mentioned in the same section as the U.S. policy of “extended deterrence.” This extended deterrence refers to the nuclear umbrella that the United States provides to Japan under the Japan-U.S. Security Treaty. Senior officials within the Japanese government perceive a lack of clarity in the relationship between this deterrence and the principle of not allowing nuclear weapons to be transported into Japan. Thus, during the revision of these documents, the two subjects will be addressed in separate chapters.
Moving forward, it is expected that the government, in coordination with the ruling party, may modify the related content. A final draft of the new documents is projected to be approved in a Cabinet meeting slated for December.
The backdrop of this policy adjustment is the continuous expansion of China’s naval activities, which include advancements in nuclear submarines, aircraft carriers, and underwater surveillance capabilities. Although Japan’s current fleet of conventionally powered submarines boasts strong stealth capabilities, it faces limitations in terms of high-speed operations and long-range deployments.
In October, the Japanese government began considering the inclusion of nuclear submarine research in its security documents. An analysis published in the Japan Times on November 12 highlighted that discussions between the ruling Liberal Democratic Party and its coalition partner, the Japan Innovation Party, have commenced regarding the revision of defense policies, with nuclear-powered submarines emerging as a pivotal topic. The Japan Innovation Party advocates for the adoption of new-generation propulsion systems to reduce the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force’s reliance on conventional submarines.
The key distinction between nuclear-powered submarines and conventional ones lies in their endurance for sustained military operations. Conventional submarines are limited by battery power and energy constraints, necessitating regular recharging. In contrast, nuclear-powered submarines can remain submerged for extended periods and execute long-range deployments at higher speeds.
On September 11, the Japan Times reported Defense Minister Shinjiro Koizumi stating that the possibility of acquiring nuclear-powered submarines cannot be dismissed. Earlier, a U.S. Navy official expressed a positive view on Japan exploring this option, indicating that Japan’s nuclear energy capabilities warrant inclusion in the discussion.
The United States’ attitude carries strategic significance. Should Japan develop nuclear-powered attack submarines, it could conduct surveillance, tracking, and deterrent missions across a broader expanse of the western Pacific, thereby alleviating some of the deployment pressures faced by U.S. forces in certain areas.
A report released by the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission (USCC) on November 18 further elucidated the threats posed by China’s naval expansion. The report noted that China is expanding its nuclear submarine forces and deploying underwater sensors, satellites, and unmanned underwater vehicles to establish a multi-layered underwater surveillance network, potentially undermining the long-held underwater military advantage of the U.S. forces.
The report particularly cautioned that in the event of military conflict over Taiwan, U.S. nuclear-powered attack submarines possess significant suppressive abilities against Chinese military amphibious forces. China is also working to enhance its capabilities to detect U.S. submarines; even if it cannot fully ascertain the locations of U.S. submarines, increasing the risks associated with their activities within the First Island Chain could potentially raise the costs of U.S. involvement in any Taiwan conflict.
This suggests that China’s military expansion is no longer confined merely to increasing the number of vessels but also includes establishing an underwater surveillance system aimed at restricting the operational freedom of U.S. forces in the western Pacific.
On November 13, the Stars and Stripes reported that Japan is facing mounting pressure from the increasingly potent maritime military forces of China, Russia, and North Korea, making nuclear-powered submarines a vital component in Japan’s reassessment of its defensive capabilities.
However, hurdles remain in Japan’s pursuit of nuclear submarine acquisition. Beyond the high costs associated with construction and maintenance, there is a pressing need to train personnel skilled in nuclear reactor technology while also addressing restrictions imposed by Japan’s Atomic Energy Basic Law concerning the use of nuclear energy.
A report from the Japan Times on October 8 cited a Japanese Defense Ministry official suggesting that while nuclear-powered submarines offer strong long-range deployment and rapid withdrawal capabilities, there remain voices of skepticism within the Liberal Democratic Party regarding the necessity of incurring such substantial costs.
Moreover, Japan’s ability to secure American nuclear reactor technology and related fuel will significantly influence whether these plans can be realized. Currently, the Japanese government has yet to make a formal procurement decision. According to the draft, pertinent research is expected to progress starting in the 2027 fiscal year, with the specifics regarding whether to introduce nuclear-powered submarines, the quantity to procure, and the timeline for construction still to be determined.