politics

BYD Ti7 Banned from EU Sales for Infringing Jaguar Land Rover’s Design Rights

Published November 21, 2026 · 3 min read
BERLIN, GERMANY – MAY 23: A woman walks past a dealership of Chinese electric car manufacturer BYD on May 23, 2025 in Berlin, Germany. BYD has overtaken Tesla in electric car sales in Europe, landing at the number 10 spot for sales in April and Tesla sliding to 11th place. Skoda and Volkswagen were at the top of the list. (Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images)

A recent ruling from a court in The Hague has brought significant attention to the ongoing legal disputes in the automotive industry, particularly involving the Chinese electric vehicle manufacturer BYD and the renowned British automotive brand Jaguar Land Rover (JLR).

The court has determined that BYD’s model, the Fangchengbao Ti7, infringes on the European design rights held for the iconic Land Rover Defender. This ruling stands as a decisive moment for JLR, which argued that the design similarities between the Ti7 and the Defender are striking, leading to a judgement that prohibits the manufacturing and sale of the Ti7 within the European Union.

On November 20, the court provided a detailed analysis of the similarities, citing features such as the pronounced shoulder line of the body, the rounded corners, the distinctive decorative panel on the C-pillar, and the flowing contours of the windows. Furthermore, it highlighted the overall proportions and silhouettes of the two vehicles, concluding that the visual impression conveyed by both vehicles is not substantially different.

In defense, BYD asserted that the two cars possess distinct characteristics in areas such as the headlights, front grille, hood, and rear design features. However, the court rejected this argument, stating that these differences are insufficient to alter the overarching visual perception that consumers might have.

As a result of this ruling, BYD’s subsidiaries in Europe have been banned from importing, producing, selling, storing, or delivering the Ti7 within EU borders. This prohibition goes into effect one week after the official delivery of the court’s decision. Infringements of this ruling could lead to substantial fines, potentially reaching up to €10 million.

The lawsuit brought by Jaguar Land Rover accuses BYD of “shamelessly” copying the Defender’s design. This controversy revolves not just around similarities between model types but also raises critical questions regarding the ability of automotive firms to leverage established design features created by competitors as selling points for their own products.

Interestingly, before this ruling, Jaguar Land Rover sought access to internal documents from BYD’s offices via the Dutch courts to investigate whether the Ti7 involved research and imitation of the Defender. Nevertheless, the court ruled on November 11 that the scope of the documents requested was excessively broad and ordered the destruction of the related materials. It is crucial to underscore that this ruling did not constitute a declaration from the court that the Ti7 did not infringe upon any design rights, and both parties continue to contest their positions in ongoing legal proceedings.

Currently, the British market is not affected by this ban. BYD had plans to begin deliveries of the Ti7 to clients in the UK as early as January 2027. However, it remains to be seen if the design rights concerning the Defender will pose legal issues in the future as further legal procedures unfold.

BYD has firmly denied any infringement, maintaining that the Ti7 is an original design and has indicated intentions to appeal the court’s decision.

It is essential to note that this ruling is part of an expedited procedure and does not represent a final judgement on the complete case. Jaguar Land Rover must initiate formal litigation within six months to maintain the validity of the ban; otherwise, the prohibition may lapse.

Not one to retreat, Jaguar Land Rover has since filed another lawsuit against BYD in the Rotterdam District Court, alleging not only copyright infringement concerning the Defender but also intentional imitation of its design. This case is set to be heard on November 25, reflecting the ongoing tensions within the competitive landscape of the automotive industry.