As Thanksgiving approaches, residents of New York City find themselves facing rising costs as they prepare for the holiday feast. Factors such as soaring fuel prices, extreme weather conditions leading to poor harvests, and overall inflation pressures have resulted in a significant increase in the prices of traditional Thanksgiving staples. Even the pecans used in desserts have seen a price surge.
While the national average price of Thanksgiving staples declined in 2025, New York stands in stark contrast, with the per-person cost of a Thanksgiving meal estimated at about $66.06—nearly 20% higher than the national average. Experts predict that prices will continue to rise this year.
Francisco Martin-Rayo, co-founder and CEO of Helios AI, highlighted in a statement to a local news outlet that nearly every item on the Thanksgiving table could further strain budgets. This is especially true for potatoes, pecans, cranberries, and turkeys, which have seen particularly noticeable price hikes.
Last year, the retail price for frozen whole turkeys was approximately $1.03 per pound; this year, that figure has climbed by around 22.3% to reach $1.26 per pound. For a 15-pound turkey, this means a cost of about $18.90, which is an increase of $3.45 from last year. Martin-Rayo pointed out that a staggering 70% rise in diesel fuel prices has significantly contributed to these increases, as the cost of transporting food—especially perishable items that require temperature control, like turkey—has gone up, ultimately affecting consumers.
Potatoes have not been spared from these price hikes either. Currently, wholesale prices are nearly 60% higher than normal levels. In New York, a box of 70 Idaho russet potatoes is priced at about $35, which is an increase of around 50% from the previous year. This hefty sum is not insignificant for many budget-conscious New Yorkers and restaurant owners.
Dessert lovers should also brace themselves for higher costs. According to Martin-Rayo, key pecan-producing regions have faced difficult weather conditions this year. Georgia experienced 68% more rainfall than in 2018, the year when Hurricane Michael devastated the local pecan industry. Meanwhile, New Mexico has seen its wettest growing season in eight years, leaving little time for recovery before the season ends in December. As a result, a smaller harvest is anticipated, leading to higher prices for pecans.
Cranberries are similarly affected this year. The crop has suffered from insufficient rainfall and wildfires, and prices are expected to rise as a result.
However, experts believe that enjoying Thanksgiving does not necessarily mean having to cut back on expenses. New Yorkers can manage their spending while still ensuring a plentiful feast by employing three main strategies: adjusting their menus, purchasing early, and shopping around for the best prices.
Martin-Rayo suggests that there is no need to strictly adhere to traditional Thanksgiving dishes. For instance, substituting sweet potatoes for regular potatoes could save money, and Brussels sprouts have had a good yield this year, potentially offering a more affordable option. Additionally, he recommends buying longer-lasting ingredients like cranberries early to take advantage of promotional opportunities. Shoppers are encouraged to compare prices between farmers’ markets, cooperatives, and supermarkets; supermarkets often have larger profit margins on canned goods, while local farms may offer better deals on bigger items like turkeys if purchased in cash.
Ultimately, the Harvard-educated entrepreneur emphasizes that the true essence of Thanksgiving lies in gathering together; the focus should be on sharing a meal with loved ones rather than being overly concerned about the menu.