On November 20, the New York City Council convened an urgent oversight hearing in response to the alarming rise in fatal fires and the risks associated with lithium-ion batteries in the city. The hearing featured senior officials from the New York City Fire Department (FDNY), who were called to explain current firefighting and enforcement measures.
City Council member Alexa Avilés from Bensonhurst emphasized the need for strict enforcement against motorcycle shops operating illegally. Meanwhile, Queens Council member Peter Koo engaged in discussions with the Fire Department regarding a proposed ban on residential battery charging, outdoor battery storage facilities, and the feasibility of enforcing these regulations.
According to FDNY statistics, there have already been 90 fire-related fatalities in New York City this year, a significant increase from the 51 deaths recorded during the same period last year. One of the critical triggers for the hearing was a tragic residential fire that occurred on November 5 in Brooklyn’s 58th Street community, claiming the lives of six individuals, all immigrants from Fuzhou, China. Alarmingly, one of the families had only moved to New York two months prior.
Council Speaker Adrienne Adams asserted that the city’s fire safety situation had reached a crisis level. This is despite the Council passing multiple related bills, as the incidence of fires and resulting casualties continues to worsen rather than show signs of improvement.
The Fire Department clarified that the cause of the November 5 fire is still under investigation and has yet to be officially determined. However, the building in question exhibited serious safety violations, including illegal subdivisions, locked bedroom doors that complicated rescue efforts, and the presence of small refrigerators, which may have hindered both rescue and evacuation attempts.
Avilés expressed gratitude that firefighters were able to remove iron bars from one of the windows that night, successfully rescuing two trapped individuals. She pointed out that many residents in her district live in sublet apartments with limited communication with landlords and may not be fluent in English, which can impede their access to fire safety information. Avilés suggested incorporating fire emergency procedures into lease agreements to ensure that tenants are well-informed before moving in.
Addressing the issue of iron bars, Fire Commander Thomas Correo mentioned that the installation of such bars is not illegal. The FDNY does not issue violation notices or citations solely due to the presence of iron bars. However, inspections can document the existence of these bars to help firefighters understand the conditions during their responses.
Avilés noted that there was a fire caused by a motorcycle just months prior in Sunset Park and insisted that the city must enhance its regulatory oversight while holding vendors selling unsafe products accountable. This week, she introduced Bill 1202 (Intro 1202), which proposes allowing the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection to shut down motorcycle shops after a second violation, instead of the current stipulation requiring three violations. Avilés argued that businesses already receive warnings after the first violation and should not be able to shift blame by claiming ignorance; she urged her colleagues to support the bill to prevent future tragedies.
Additionally, Avilés proposed exploring the creation of heat-resistant battery bags for delivery workers to safely store batteries after their shifts. Correo noted that this initiative is still under consideration, but he emphasized that the ordinary fireproof document bags differ significantly from storage bags designed to prevent battery fires; the former protects against external burns, while the latter is intended to contain internal flare-ups. Past tests conducted by the Fire Department’s academy have not demonstrated the effectiveness of such bags in controlling battery fires, necessitating thorough safety assessments before promoting their use.
Koo focused on strengthening the mechanisms for tracking and enforcing complaints regarding dangerous charging practices reported by the public. He stated that his office frequently receives complaints about illegal charging in apartments or private spaces and often receives little to no follow-up from the FDNY after these complaints are referred. Koo demanded clarity on the investigation process, inspection standards, and response mechanisms.
In response, Correo indicated that over the past four years, the Fire Department has received more than 900 related complaints. In situations deemed to have immediate dangers, they dispatch personnel promptly, and if necessary, special inspection teams will intervene. He assured that the FDNY commits to confirming responses within 12 hours of complaints, issuing notices, citations, or even pursuing criminal prosecution when warranted. Currently, the resolution rate for these cases exceeds 95%.
Addressing concerns raised by Koo about whether complainants can receive updates on investigation outcomes, Correo promised to verify the customer service center’s response procedures and committed to providing relevant data to the City Council. He elaborated that unless individuals inside a building consent or if clear signs of emergency danger such as smoke are present, the Fire Department usually cannot enter private premises and would need to arrange for a follow-up inspection under other circumstances.
Koo challenged Correo on the possibility that some cases may be closed without access to a dwelling or contact with the residents, to which Correo denied, emphasizing that the special inspection team actively continues its enforcement duties.
Another focal point of the discussion was Koo’s Bill 920 (Intro 920), which seeks to eliminate exemptions for charging motorcycles in residential areas, further restricting the storage and charging of lithium batteries within households.
Fire Department Chief Lillian Bonsignore expressed agreement with the need to store and charge batteries outdoors but opposed the complete removal of exemptions due to practical implementation challenges. She noted that many apartment residents lack alternative storage options, making it essential to strike a balance between reducing fire risk and accommodating residents’ living conditions. Furthermore, facilities must be capable of preventing fire spread, yet there are still not many mature and verified safe storage products currently available on the market.
Koo highlighted the importance of these amendments, stressing that the intent is to prevent the accumulation of numerous batteries within apartments. He stated that he has spoken with delivery workers who, due to daily demands, may store three to four lithium batteries at home, underscoring the need to relocate these batteries outside residences to mitigate risks for entire buildings.
Bonsignore affirmed the fundamental goals of the proposed legislation but insisted that solutions must ensure safety while remaining practical for residents to comply with. Correo added that the city is collaborating with industry stakeholders and battery cabinet manufacturers to explore specialized “battery cabinets” and assess new technologies and usability.
In closing, Koo referenced a report from the Fire Department indicating that there have been 18 fire-related deaths this year associated with issues such as extension cords or power strips. The fire officials responded by stating that the safest practice is to minimize the use of extension cords or power strips. When charging motorcycle batteries, original chargers should be used directly plugged into wall outlets, and charging should occur in safe locations away from flammable materials, avoiding entrances or areas exposed to direct sunlight. Furthermore, it’s crucial to monitor batteries for indicators of malfunction, such as unusual odors, shape or color changes, leaks, or strange noises.