On November 11, a tragic incident occurred in Flatbush, Brooklyn, where a three-story residential building collapsed, resulting in the deaths of eight individuals. This devastating event has sparked intense public concern regarding construction safety and government oversight. As details about the construction site and its background began to surface, local residents living near the homeless shelter project on Coyle Street in the nearby Sheepshead Bay area raised significant questions. They alleged that the Department of Buildings (DOB) might have approved plans for new construction and excavation work without the necessary stormwater management permits and called for a comprehensive investigation into the city’s approval processes.
The concerns were voiced by Mr. Eddie Ye, a representative of the local residents. He previously appealed to the New York City Board of Standards and Appeals (BSA) regarding the stormwater management issues tied to the homeless shelter project on Coyle Street.
Mr. Ye pointed out that Robert Fischman, the owner involved in the construction project at 2621-2631 Bedford Avenue near the site of the building collapse, had also signed the land subdivision application for 2134 Coyle Street as an authorized representative. Residents believe that there is a troubling connection between the land transactions and the approvals of engineering work for these two projects.
Following the building collapse in Flatbush, Mr. Ye began closely monitoring the developments. His first focus was on the stormwater management permit issues related to the Bedford Avenue construction site.
According to the DOB’s project application documents, the new impervious surface area for the project exceeds 5,000 square feet, which, under regulations, requires it to undergo stormwater discharge review by the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP). However, upon reviewing the records, Mr. Ye discovered that the DOB ultimately accepted a disclaimer signed by the developer instead of a stormwater management permit issued by the DEP, yet still approved the excavation work.
Mr. Ye argued that actions taken by the developer to reinforce the neighboring building’s exterior and foundation cannot replace the legally required stormwater management permit. In essence, the issue extends beyond whether safety measures were in place during construction; it pertains to whether the DOB issued excavation approvals without the necessary permits in hand.
Moreover, Mr. Ye highlighted that similar administrative inconsistencies were present in the project at 2134 Coyle Street. The new construction plans for this project were approved on April 2, 2024, while the required stormwater management permit had not yet been obtained at that time.
He also connected the timing of the approvals with subsequent land transactions: after the construction plans for the homeless shelter project on Coyle Street were approved in April 2024, the current developer, Slate, purchased the plot for over $20 million in May of the same year. By June, Fischman used the proceeds from this real estate transaction to acquire a plot at 2625 Bedford Avenue for $3.99 million.
Faced with the troubling circumstances surrounding both projects, where construction was approved despite the absence of stormwater permits, Mr. Ye questioned whether these developments and subsequent transactions would have transpired without the DOB’s apparent violations in the approval process. He is urging the city government to conduct a thorough investigation and clarify whether there are systemic regulatory gaps involved. If it is confirmed that the approval processes were violated, Mr. Ye insists that the DOB should issue stop-work orders for the affected projects.
He emphasized that the Flatbush building collapse serves as a stark warning about construction safety. The city government must not wait for another tragedy to occur before addressing important issues related to building regulation.